Make Their Day
Themed Birthday Cakes They'll Never Forget
From cartoon characters and hand-sculpted 3D designs to elegant floral cakes for milestone birthdays, every Not Just Cake birthday cake is built around the person celebrating. Send us inspiration photos, a favorite hobby, or a wild idea — we will make it real.
Any Theme, Any Age
Sports, cartoons, hobbies, sculpted 3D builds, number cakes, photo cakes — bring us your vision.
Pick Your Flavors
Mix-and-match sponges, fillings, and buttercreams. Vanilla bean to red velvet to lemon-blueberry.
Short Lead Times
Most birthday cakes need just 1–2 weeks notice. Call for rush orders when you can.
Sizes & Options
Small Round
$70 – $95
6"–8" single-tier cake — perfect for small parties, intimate celebrations, and smash cakes.
- Serves 8–24 guests
- One flavor + filling
- Buttercream finish with custom decoration
- Pickup at storefront
Themed Celebration
$95 – $175
Our most popular size. Custom themed design, photo print, or character build for birthdays up to ~50 guests.
- Serves 30–50 guests
- 8"–10" single tier or 6"+8" two tier
- Hand-decorated topper or sculpted accents
- Photo or edible image add-on available
Sculpted 3D / Milestone
Starting at $175
Fully sculpted 3D cakes (cars, animals, objects) and elegant milestone cakes (16th, 30th, 50th).
- Serves 40+ guests
- Hand-carved or stacked construction
- Edible figurines, gold leaf, or hand-painted details
- Consultation included
Pricing varies based on design complexity, size, and decorations. Final quotes are provided after a consultation.
Birthday Cakes Examples
Frequently Asked About Birthday Cakes
How much notice do I need to give for a birthday cake?
Standard birthday cakes need 1–2 weeks lead time. Sculpted 3D designs or photo-perfect themed cakes are best booked 2–3 weeks ahead. Call us at (918) 260-2565 for rush requests — we will tell you honestly what is doable.
How big of a cake do I need for [X] guests?
A rough guide: a 6" round serves 8–12, an 8" round serves 16–24, a 10" round serves 28–38, and a 12" round serves 40–50. Two-tier setups serve more. Tell us your headcount and we will recommend the right size.
Can you copy a cake design I saw online?
We will get as close as possible while bringing our own craftsmanship to it. Send us the photo so we can quote accurately. We do not copy other bakers exactly out of respect for their original art, but we can absolutely match a style, color scheme, or theme.
Do you do smash cakes for first birthdays?
Yes! Smash cakes are a fun specialty. We can match them to a larger family cake for "matching set" photos, or do a standalone with a custom theme.
Can I add cupcakes or cookies to my birthday cake order?
Yes — combo orders are encouraged. Cookies start at $25/dozen, cupcakes at $35/dozen. They can be designed to coordinate with the cake theme.
What flavors are most popular for kids vs. adults?
Kids tend to love vanilla bean, chocolate, strawberry, and confetti. Adults gravitate toward red velvet, lemon, marble, and our seasonal blueberry-lemon. Every cake can be split-flavor per tier or per layer.
Ready to Order Your Birthday Cakes?
Tell us about your event and Regina will personally get back to you within 24 hours.