Tiny Edible Art
Hand-Decorated Sugar Cookies for Every Theme
Royal-icing artwork, intricate piping, and custom shapes — every Not Just Cake sugar cookie is painted by hand to match your event theme. Wedding favors, baby shower treats, holiday gifts, corporate logos, party tables — we shape them, ice them, and box them so they arrive picture-perfect.
Custom Shapes
Any cookie cutter we own, or new custom cutters for your specific theme.
Hand-Painted Icing
Royal icing artwork — flooded, piped, painted, stenciled, and detailed by hand.
Gift-Ready Packaging
Individually wrapped, boxed, or arranged on display platters for parties and favors.
Sizes & Options
Classic Dozen
$25 – $35 / dozen
Standard themed cookie set — one design, simple-to-medium complexity, perfect for parties and gifts.
- 12 cookies, single design
- Pre-made cutter shape
- 1–2 royal icing colors
- Individually wrapped on request
Custom Themed Set
$35 – $50 / dozen
Mixed shapes and designs coordinated to one theme — most popular for baby showers, weddings, and parties.
- 3–6 different design variations
- Multi-color royal icing
- Hand-piped details and accents
- Designed to match your event palette
Custom Cutters / Photo Cookies
$50+ / dozen
Brand new custom cookie cutter for your logo, character, or unique shape — plus highly detailed edible-image cookies.
- Custom 3D-printed cutter included
- Hand-painted photo or character cookies
- Logo / corporate orders welcomed
- Larger minimum order (typically 2 dozen+)
Pricing varies based on design complexity, size, and decorations. Final quotes are provided after a consultation.
Decorated Sugar Cookies Examples
Frequently Asked About Decorated Sugar Cookies
How many cookies do I need for my event?
Plan for 1–2 cookies per guest if cookies are one of several desserts, or 2–3 per guest if they are the headline treat. For wedding or shower favors (one per guest), order in dozens — we cannot break partial dozens.
Can you make a custom cookie shape?
Yes. If we do not already own the cutter, we can have a custom cookie cutter 3D-printed for your design — typically adds 1 week to the lead time and a small one-time fee for the cutter (which you keep).
How long do decorated cookies stay fresh?
Properly stored at room temperature in a sealed container, decorated sugar cookies stay fresh for up to 2 weeks. The royal icing actually helps seal in moisture. Do not refrigerate — humidity ruins the icing finish.
Can cookies be shipped?
No — we only offer local pickup or delivery within the McAlester, OK area. Sugar cookies travel well in a car for several hours, but we do not pack them for mail shipping at this time.
Do you do gluten-free, vegan, or allergen-friendly cookies?
On request, yes — but our kitchen is not allergen-free certified. We can prepare a separate small batch with specific accommodations. Discuss your needs at booking so we can plan the production order.
Can you match my exact color palette?
Yes. Send us color swatches, hex codes, or even physical samples (ribbon, fabric, paint chips) and we will mix royal icing to match. Vibrant deeply-saturated colors (deep red, black, navy) require more food coloring and may have a slightly different flavor profile.
Ready to Order Your Decorated Sugar Cookies?
Tell us about your event and Regina will personally get back to you within 24 hours.